WordPress vs Wix vs Squarespace: Which Is Right for Contractors?
For a home service business that wants to grow through Google, self-hosted WordPress is usually the better long-term choice: you own the site outright, you can add as many service and area pages as you need and you can move it to any host. Wix and Squarespace are easier to start with and fine for a simple site, but you're renting space on their platform.
That isn't a knock on Wix or Squarespace. They're good products that solve a different problem. What matters is picking the one that fits where your business is going as well as where it is today.
The short version
- Wix and Squarespace are all-in-one hosted builders: quick to start, but you rent rather than own.
- Self-hosted WordPress gives you full ownership and room to grow, but needs regular updates.
- All three can rank on Google; structure and content matter more than the platform.
- Moving off Wix or Squarespace later usually means a rebuild.
- If Google and AI search are your main lead source, plan for a site that can scale to many pages.
The quick comparison
- Wix. Drag-and-drop builder with hosting included. Easy for a beginner, lots of templates, monthly subscription. Your site lives on Wix and can’t be exported to another host as a working site.
- Squarespace. Polished templates and hosting included, also on a subscription. Strong for visual, portfolio-style sites. Export options are limited, so leaving usually means rebuilding.
- WordPress (self-hosted). Free, open-source software you install on hosting you choose. Huge range of themes and plugins, full control of files and data. Needs someone to keep it updated and secure.
One clarification: WordPress.com is a hosted service with plans, and WordPress.org is the free software you run on your own hosting. When web designers recommend WordPress for a business site, they almost always mean the self-hosted version.
Ownership: renting vs owning
This is the biggest difference for a contractor who plans to be in business for years.
With Wix or Squarespace, you own your content and your domain, but the site itself only works on their platform. If prices go up, features change or you outgrow it, you can’t pick up the site and move it. You rebuild it somewhere else.
With self-hosted WordPress, the files and database are yours. You can switch hosting companies, switch web designers or bring the work in-house, and the site comes with you. That matters if you’ve ever been stuck with a designer who won’t hand over access. Our guide on website ownership covers what should be in your name whichever platform you choose.
SEO and growth
All three platforms can rank on Google. A well-structured Wix site with strong service pages will beat a messy WordPress site every time. The platform isn’t magic.
Where the difference shows up is growth. Home service businesses that win in search tend to end up with a lot of pages: one for each service, one for each area they want work in, plus answers to the questions customers ask. As that grows, you want fine control over page titles, URLs, internal links, schema markup, redirects and page templates. WordPress handles that with the most flexibility. Wix and Squarespace have improved their SEO settings, but you’re working inside the options they give you.
The same goes for AI search. Getting recommended by Google AI Overviews or ChatGPT depends on clear, well-structured content and markup that describes your business. The more control you have over that, the easier it is to get right. That’s why we build most client sites on WordPress; see WordPress web design.
Cost and upkeep
Wix and Squarespace bundle hosting, security and updates into a monthly plan. You pay every month for as long as the site is live, and premium features or apps can add to that. In return you don’t have to think about updates.
WordPress software is free, but you pay for hosting, any premium themes or plugins and someone’s time to keep it updated, backed up and secure. Skipped updates are how WordPress sites get hacked or break. If you don’t want to handle that, a website maintenance plan takes care of it.
Neither option is automatically cheaper. A simple Wix site you build yourself costs less up front. A WordPress site built properly costs more to set up, but tends to hold its value because you aren’t rebuilding when you outgrow it.
Speed, features and integrations
Hosted builders handle performance for you, within limits. Heavy templates with lots of effects can still be slow on a phone, and you only have so much control over the code.
WordPress speed depends on how it’s built. A lean theme on good hosting can be very fast. A site stacked with page-builder plugins on cheap hosting can be painfully slow. That’s why build quality matters more than the platform name. See website speed and leads.
For integrations, think about what your business uses: a CRM, a scheduling tool, financing applications, call tracking. Most popular tools connect to all three platforms, but WordPress usually gives you more ways to connect them and more control over how forms and tracking work.
What matters more than the platform
Owners often blame the platform when the real problem is the build. We regularly see WordPress sites that are slow and invisible on Google, and Squarespace sites that do a decent job. The things that decide whether a contractor site brings in calls are mostly platform-neutral:
- Is there a clear page for each service you want more of?
- Does the site say plainly which parts of Toronto and the GTA you cover?
- Is the copy specific to your trade, or generic filler?
- Is it obvious how to call or request a quote on a phone?
- Are reviews and real job photos close to the call button?
- Are calls and form fills tracked?
Get those right and almost any platform can produce leads. Get them wrong and switching platforms won’t fix anything. The platform choice matters most for the long run: how far the site can grow, how much control you have and whether you can take it with you. That’s the lens to use when you decide.
Which one should you pick?
A straight recommendation by situation:
- Just starting, tight budget, want to do it yourself: Wix or Squarespace is a reasonable place to begin. Keep your domain in your own registrar account so you can move later.
- Mostly referral-based, need a credible online presence: any of the three works. Pick the one you or your designer can maintain easily.
- Want Google and AI search to be a major lead source: self-hosted WordPress, built lean, with room for service and area pages. This is the setup most growing contractors end up on.
- Already on Wix or Squarespace and stuck: it may be time for a redesign onto a platform you fully control, with redirects so you keep what ranks.
If you aren’t sure whether your current platform is holding you back, book a free website teardown. We’ll tell you whether the problem is the platform or the way the site was built, which are often two different things.
Common questions
Can a Wix site rank on Google?
Yes. Google ranks pages, not platforms. A Wix site with clear service pages, good content and a strong Google Business Profile can rank well. The limits show up when you want many pages, detailed control over technical SEO or to move the site elsewhere later.
Is WordPress hard to manage?
Editing text and photos is straightforward once it's set up properly. The harder part is updates, backups and security. Many owners leave that to a maintenance plan so they only touch the site when they want to change content.
Can you move my Wix or Squarespace site to WordPress?
Yes, though it's a rebuild rather than a direct transfer. We recreate the pages, improve them along the way and redirect every old URL to its new home so you keep any rankings you've earned.
What do you build sites on?
Most of our client sites are built on WordPress, kept lean without heavy page-builder bloat, so they load fast and you own everything. If another platform suits your situation better, we'll say so on the strategy call.